Limud Torah

SEIF 4 (Cont.)
The Gra says that the Tur who holds that R' Yehuda is not arguing with the Tanna Kamma (according to the Bais Yosef's explanation) and holds like Rashi that when removing clothes by loosening a tight press, it is considered demolishing. However, if the press is already loose, everyone holds it is permitted to remove the clothes because it is not similar to demolishing. Using this reasoning, we are not forced to use the answer supplied by the Magid Mishna which interprets that the Tanna Kamma is making a Gezaira that if someone loosens the press which is already partially loosened, he would come to loosen it when it is tight.